top of page

Should I Repair or Replace My Garage Door?

Updated: May 22

Your garage door isn't opening smoothly anymore, leaving you wondering what to do next.

Garage doors typically last between 15-30 years before needing replacement or major repairs.

This article will guide you through deciding whether a repair will suffice or it's time for a brand-new door. 

Let's find the best fix for your garage!

Key Takeaways

  • Assess the type of damage and how much your garage door is affected to decide between repair or replacement. Small issues like broken springs or dents might just need repairs, while extensive damage could mean it's time for a new door.

  • Consider energy efficiency when choosing to fix or replace your garage door; newer models can save you money on heating and cooling costs by providing better insulation against the weather.

  • Look at the age of your current garage door; older ones may not have modern safety features and could be costly to maintain, pushing towards replacement as a smarter choice.

  • Pay attention to signs that suggest replacing rather than repairing: if your door stops suddenly, leans significantly, feels very heavy when moving, or contributes to high energy bills.

  • Child safety is vital; ensure that any repair or new installation includes up-to-date features like auto-reverse mechanisms and sensors to prevent accidents.

Aaron's Garage Door Company provides expert garage door repair and installation services in Clark County, WA. If you're seeking reliable assistance, look no further! Be sure to check us out for your garage door needs!

Factors to Consider When Deciding to Repair or Replace Your Garage Door

Replacing Your Garage Door

Consider the type and extent of the damage, as well as the age of your garage door. Also take into account energy efficiency, aesthetic appeal, and child safety features when making your decision.

Types of Damage, Extent of the Damage, Cost, Age of the Door, Energy Efficiency

Deciding between garage door repair or replacement involves multiple factors. Assessing the condition and functionality of your current garage door system is crucial.

  • Types of Damage: Assess the damage to your garage door. If you notice broken springs, damaged panels, or issues with the lifting mechanism, these may either be repaired or signal a need for total replacement.

  • Extent of the Damage: Determine how much of the door is affected. A single panel might be an easy fix, whereas multiple damaged panels often require more extensive work.

  • Cost: Analyzing repair costs versus replacement can guide your decision. While repairing may seem less expensive upfront, a new garage door might save money in the long run by requiring less maintenance and offering better energy efficiency.

  • Age of the Door: Older garage doors might lack modern features that improve security and efficiency. If your door has been properly maintained yet still struggles to operate smoothly, it could be time to consider a new installation.

  • Energy Efficiency: Energy bills can soar with an old, inefficient door, especially for attached garages. New garage doors offer improved insulation and seal against weather, which can lower energy costs significantly over time.

Aesthetic Appeal

Old garage door replacement

Your garage door does more than just protect your car; it plays a significant role in the curb appeal of your home. If your old garage door is dented, peeling, or simply outdated, it can drag down the overall look of your property.

A fresh garage door replacement might be all you need to give your house a facelift and boost its value. Modern vehicles and homes often pair well with newer garage doors that have sleek designs and are available in various colors and materials to complement any style.

Adding windows or choosing a door with intricate patterns can also inject personality into your home's exterior. Even if the rest of your house looks great, a worn-out old door can stand out like a sore thumb.

Consider how replacing your garage door could bring together the visual harmony of your space while providing improved security for everything behind it—from simple replacement options to low maintenance solutions, think about how much aesthetic impact a new door could have on revamping not only the view from the street but also on reflecting pride in ownership.

Child Safety Features

Child safety features on your garage door are critical. These mechanisms prevent doors from closing if something or someone is in the way, reducing the risk of injury. Many modern garage door systems include sensors that detect objects under the door and auto-reverse functions to keep kids safe.

It's also important to have a reliable emergency release that adults can easily access in case of an accident.

Regular maintenance ensures these safety features remain operational. Make sure to test the auto-reverse system monthly by placing an object like a piece of wood on the ground where the door would close and checking if it reverses when it hits this obstacle.

If you're considering repair or replacement, assess whether your current garage door opener has all necessary child safety features up-to-date with industry standards. A newer model might provide enhanced security options for peace of mind when little ones are around.

Signs That It's Time to Replace Your Garage Door

Replace Your Garage Door

If your garage door suddenly stops, has damaged panels, feels heavy or leans to one side, it may be time for a replacement. High energy costs and break-ins are also signs that it's time for a new garage door.

Sudden Stopping, Damaged Panels, Heaviness, Leaning

If your garage door suddenly stops while opening or closing, it may indicate a problem with the motor or the track. Damaged panels not only affect the appearance but also compromise the security and insulation of your garage. If your garage door feels heavier than usual, it could be due to issues with the springs or opener. Leaning of the garage door may signal structural problems, which can impact its functionality and safety. Proper maintenance and timely repairs can help prolong the life of your garage door and ensure smooth operation.


Age is a crucial factor when deciding whether to repair or replace your garage door. Older doors are more prone to wear and tear, leading to frequent malfunctions and safety issues.

Additionally, older doors may lack modern safety features, making them less secure for your family and belongings. Energy efficiency is another concern with aging garage doors, as they often have poor insulation that can increase heating and cooling costs.

Considering the age of your garage door is essential in determining whether it's time for a replacement or if it can still be effectively repaired. A newer model will not only provide improved security and energy efficiency but also enhance the overall aesthetic appeal of your home.

High Energy Costs

If your garage door is old and inefficient, it could be contributing to high energy costs. Poor insulation and worn weather stripping can lead to heat loss in the winter and cool air escaping in the summer.

This forces your HVAC system to work harder, resulting in higher energy bills. Upgrading to a new, energy-efficient garage door can improve insulation, reduce drafts, and lower your overall energy usage.

Consider replacing your current garage door with an insulated model that offers better thermal resistance. Look for options that provide natural light while maintaining energy efficiency.


Garage doors are often a point of entry for break-ins. Ensure the security of your home by promptly replacing or repairing any damage to your garage door that could compromise its ability to keep intruders out.

Older doors and those with compromised panels or faulty locking mechanisms are particularly vulnerable.

Damaged garage doors can be an invitation for burglars, compromising the safety of your home and belongings. Regular maintenance and upgrades to your garage door opener can also significantly enhance security deterrents against potential break-ins.

When to Repair Your Garage Door

If your garage door suddenly malfunctions or experiences minor damage, it may be a good time to repair it. A heavy or leaning door can also indicate the need for repairs to keep your garage running smoothly and safely.

Sudden Malfunctioning

If your garage door suddenly malfunctions, it could be due to issues with the opener, springs, or other mechanical components. Sudden malfunctioning may also point to electrical problems.

A professional inspection is crucial when faced with a sudden malfunction, especially if the door won't open or close properly. Ignoring a sudden malfunction can lead to further damage and compromise the security of your home.

Consider reaching out to a local garage door service for immediate assistance when experiencing sudden malfunctions. Regular maintenance can help prevent unexpected breakdowns and keep your garage door running smoothly.

Minor Damage

If your garage door is experiencing minor damage such as small dents or scratches, it is often practical to opt for repairs instead of a full replacement. Minor damage can be efficiently addressed by local garage door dealers, saving you the cost and hassle of installing an entirely new door.

By having the physical damage fixed promptly, you can ensure that your garage door continues to operate smoothly and maintain its overall aesthetic appeal without incurring labor costs associated with replacing multiple panels.

Addressing minor damage promptly also helps in maintaining a quieter operation of your garage door over time, contributing to a more cost-effective solution than opting for an entire replacement door.

Heavy Door

A heavy garage door could indicate an issue with the springs or cables, which are crucial for smooth operation. When a door feels heavier than usual, it puts extra strain on the opener and can lead to premature wear and tear.

Neglecting this problem could result in more significant repairs down the line, so it's important to address it promptly.

If your garage door feels exceptionally heavy when opening or closing, don't ignore it as a minor inconvenience. Heavy doors may pose safety risks and should be inspected by a professional to ensure they function properly and safely over time.

Keeping up with regular maintenance can help prevent heavier-than-usual doors from becoming a bigger issue in the future.


If your garage door is leaning to one side, it could indicate a serious issue with the door's balance or structural integrity. Leaning can be caused by issues such as damaged or loose tracks, or spring tension problems.

It's crucial to address this problem promptly to prevent further damage and ensure the safety of your family and property.

Ignoring a leaning garage door can lead to more severe malfunctions and potentially costly repairs down the line. To avoid potential safety hazards and inconvenience, it is advisable to seek professional assistance if you notice any leaning in your garage door.


In deciding whether to repair or replace your garage door, weigh factors such as damage type and extent, age, energy efficiency, and aesthetic appeal. Signs like sudden stopping, damaged panels, heaviness, leaning, high energy costs, or break-ins might indicate a need for replacement. 

However, issues like sudden malfunctions or minor damages could be more suitably addressed with repairs. 

If you're uncertain or need professional guidance, don't hesitate to contact us for expert advice tailored to your specific situation.


1. How do I decide if I should repair or replace my garage door?

Consider several factors like the age of your door, cost effectiveness, and whether it's a single part or the entire garage door that needs attention.

2. When is repairing my garage door a good option?

Repairing your garage door is wise if it has minor issues like needing new torsion springs or if right maintenance can extend its life without frequent breakdowns.

3. What are signs that I might need to replace my entire door instead of repairing it?

If your old garage doors have major damages, don't operate safely with average repairs, or appear outdated which could affect your home's value, then replacing them might be best.

4. Are there benefits to getting a brand-new garage door over just making repairs?

Yes! New doors can enhance curb appeal for any home improvement project and may come with updated features that old garage doors lack, like modern insulation and contemporary designs.

5. Is replacing a garage door more expensive than repairing one?

Generally, replacing an entire garage door costs more up front compared to small repairs but consider this against long-term savings from improved energy efficiency and fewer future repairs.

58 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page